google-site-verification=FNFrlMGRn5TIdN3I5djh-H1QSKd3Qz1m1O1751Hn8jY

Court dismisses Navy officer’s suit over rejected resignation, awards N2m cost

 

The National Industrial Court has dismissed a suit filed by a Nigerian Navy officer, identified only as “Anthony”, challenging the refusal of the Chief of Naval Staff and the Nigerian Navy to approve his application for voluntary resignation before completing eight years of service.

The court, presided over by the President of the National Industrial Court, Justice Benedict Kanyip, held that officers enlisted under the Direct Short Service Commission (DSSC) were required to complete an initial eight-year period of service before seeking voluntary resignation.

Justice Kanyip ruled that the naval authorities did not violate Section 306 of the 1999 Constitution by declining to approve Anthony’s resignation before the expiration of his mandatory service period.

The court also dismissed the claimant’s argument that the refusal to approve his resignation amounted to forced labour and a violation of his fundamental rights.

Anthony had told the court that he was commissioned into the Nigerian Navy in March 2015 under the Direct Short Service Commission Course 22 as a Surgeon Sub-Lieutenant.

He said he applied for voluntary resignation through a letter dated September 28, 2020, which he claimed was received and acknowledged by the Chief of Naval Staff.

Following the failure of the naval authorities to act on his request, Anthony said he submitted another resignation letter dated February 18, 2021, which was acknowledged by the defendants on February 25, 2021.

Dissatisfied with the refusal to approve his resignation, he approached the court, seeking declarations that he had a constitutional right to voluntarily leave the Nigerian Navy and that his resignation letter of September 28, 2020, was valid and effective.

However, the Chief of Naval Staff and the Nigerian Navy, in their defence, maintained that Anthony was commissioned under the Direct Short Service Commission scheme and had accepted the terms and conditions of service contained in the Harmonised Terms and Conditions of Service for Officers, 2017 (Revised).

The defendants argued that the conditions prescribed a minimum initial engagement period of eight years for officers recruited under the scheme.

They further told the court that Anthony had served for approximately five years when he applied for resignation and that his request was expressly rejected in a letter dated November 2, 2020, because he had not fulfilled the mandatory service requirement.

Anthony’s counsel had relied on Section 306 of the 1999 Constitution, as amended, arguing that the provision guaranteed every public officer the right to resign upon the receipt of a resignation letter by the appropriate authority.

The claimant’s lawyer also argued that the refusal of the naval authorities to approve his client’s resignation amounted to forced labour and violated his constitutional rights and relevant International Labour Organisation conventions.

But counsel to the defendants, Al-Ameen Abubakar, countered that members of the Armed Forces could not exercise an unrestricted right to resign without regard to the statutory and service conditions governing their engagement.

He urged the court to dismiss the suit, insisting that the claimant was bound by the conditions he accepted upon enlistment.

In his judgment, Justice Kanyip first considered the issue of limitation and held that the action was statute-barred under the Public Officers Protection Act.

The judge also held that Anthony had slept on his rights by allowing more than five years to elapse before instituting the action.

On the substantive issues, the court held that constitutional provisions relating to the right to resign, the prohibition of forced labour and the responsibilities of the Armed Forces must be interpreted harmoniously rather than in isolation.

Justice Kanyip considered Sections 1, 34, 217, 254C and 306 of the 1999 Constitution, alongside International Labour Organisation Conventions 29 and 105.

Although the court acknowledged that the Constitution did not expressly exclude members of the military from its application, it held that the right to resign must be considered within the broader constitutional and international legal framework governing military service.

The judge reasoned that Anthony had voluntarily joined the Nigerian Navy under the Direct Short Service Commission scheme and undertaken to comply with its initial eight-year engagement requirement.

He therefore held that the naval authorities were entitled to insist that the claimant fulfil the agreed service period before seeking voluntary resignation.

On the allegation of forced labour, the court ruled that the refusal to approve Anthony’s premature resignation did not constitute forced or compulsory labour under Section 34 of the Constitution or ILO Conventions 29 and 105.

The court noted that the claimant was not being compelled to serve beyond the stipulated initial engagement period, adding that he had been informed that he could submit another application for resignation upon completing the mandatory eight years.

Consequently, Justice Kanyip dismissed the suit and awarded N2 million in costs against the claimant in favour of the Chief of Naval Staff and the Nigerian Navy, directing that the money be paid within 30 days.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back To Top